The unique Boat Service medal which purports to have been awarded to Lieutenant Andrew Bulger, Royal Newfoundland Fencibles, for the capture of two American schooners in Lake Huron in 1814; he also received the medal for Fort Detroit and Chrystler’s Farm

Naval General Service 1793-1840, 1 clasp, 3 & 6 Sep Boat Service 1814 (A. B...... Lieut. R.N. Fencibles) surname mostly erased but parts of some other letters discernible, ‘Fencibles’ engraved in contemporary serif capitals, the clasp rather buckled and the medal generally worn overall, therefore good fine £2000-3000

This unique clasp was issued to Lieutenant Andrew Bulger, Royal Newfoundland Fencible Infantry, for the capture of the American schooners Tigress and Scorpion by boats in the Detour Passage, Lake Huron. This medal was found recently in an Antique store in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada, hidden in an old box of clothing buttons. The dealer has no knowledge of where the buttons came from or how long they were in the back of his shop. With the initial ‘A’ and surname beginning with ‘B’, there does not appear to be any other possible recipient on the rolls as a Lieut. R.N. See web site for enlargement of clasp and naming details.

Andrew Bulger was born in Newfoundland on 30 November 1790, and was appointed ensign in the recently established Newfoundland Regiment of Fencible Infantry on 26 October 1804, and within two years he received his commission as lieutenant. He served with his unit, which became the Royal Newfoundland Regiment in 1806, in Newfoundland, Nova Scotia, and Lower Canada until the outbreak of war with the United States in 1812 when he was sent to the Niagara frontier in Upper Canada to serve under Major-General Isaac Brock. He was present at the capture of Detroit in August 1812, and that fall he was attached to the naval force which harassed the enemy along the upper St Lawrence. He also participated in the battles of Fort George (Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ont.) and Stoney Creek in May and June 1813, and in the battle of Crystler’s Farm in November [For these actions he received the M.G.S. medal with clasps, Fort Detroit and Chrystler’s Farm]. As adjutant to Lieutenant-Colonel Robert McDouall, Bulger was with the reinforcements sent to Fort Michilimackinac (Mackinac Island, Mich.) in 1814. The force of 10 officers and some 200 men left Kingston in early February, and after a difficult winter trek by way of Lake Simcoe to Georgian Bay they proceeded by boat, arriving at the fort on 18 May. The repulse of an American attack on 4 August, coupled with the daring capture of the American schooners Tigress and Scorpion in early September, ensured British supremacy on the upper Great Lakes for the duration of the war. Bulger was prominent in both of these engagements and was slightly wounded during the boarding of the Tigress.

In October Bulger, with the local rank of captain, was appointed commandant of Fort McKay, at Prairie du Chien (Wis.) on the upper Mississippi River, an American fort captured in July by William McKay, commander of the Michigan Fencibles, a provincial corps. The situation at Fort McKay was both dangerous and delicate, but through determined leadership Bulger preserved the security of the 200 French Canadian inhabitants of the area and maintained the Indians’ allegiance to the British flag. In early January 1815 he suppressed a near mutiny among the Michigan Fencibles, stationed at the fort, by convening a general court martial and having the three worst offenders summarily flogged.

Bulger also had an ongoing quarrel with Robert Dickson, agent and superintendent to the Western Indians, stationed at Prairie du Chien, over relations with the Indian allies. In his instructions Bulger was given jurisdiction over the distribution of provisions and gifts to the Indian families, and the young officer refused to allow the Indian agent to interfere with his authority. Dickson was finally recalled to Michilimackinac early in 1815. In spite of this unfortunate power struggle, Bulger’s general conduct was endorsed by the inhabitants of Prairie du Chien in an address of 15 January 1815, thanking him for his leadership and protection. McDouall was equally complimentary and praised him for his “judicious, manly, and energetic conduct.”

News of the peace settlement signed at Ghent on 24 December 1814 reached Prairie du Chien in April 1815. Bulger succeeded, with some difficulty, in convincing the Indian allies on the upper Mississippi to ratify the treaty, which recognized American sovereignty over the area south of the lakes. Then on 24 May, after distributing food and gifts among them, he burned the fort and abandoned the area to American occupation. He proceeded by way of Michilimackinac to Quebec where he learned to his “mortification” that he had not received the captaincy to which McDouall had recommended him in late 1814. The Royal Newfoundland Regiment was disbanded in June 1816 and he was placed on the half-pay list as lieutenant. Bulger spent most of the next few years in England where he attempted to gain remuneration for his services during the war, a military appointment, and promotion to half-pay captain. Although his several applications were always fully supported by senior British officers, it was not until 1820 that he finally succeeded in obtaining a compensation of £500 and military allowance equal to the half pay of a captain [in the Royal Navy].

In the winter of 1821–22 Hudson’s Bay Company director Andrew Colvile, upon the recommendation of Sir Gordon Drummond and on behalf of the executors of the estate of Lord Selkirk, offered Bulger a three-year appointment as secretary and registrar for the Red River settlement (Man.). He was also to form and train a militia force of 100 settlers. Bulger accepted the offer and, in order to bolster his authority in the colony, he was made governor locum tenens of Assiniboia, at a salary of £250. He arrived at Red River on 28 June 1822 and within a few weeks he was so thoroughly disillusioned with his “life of slavery and of exposure to the insults and threats of some of the most worthless of God’s creatures, in one of the most miserable countries on the face of the earth,” that he submitted a year’s notice of his intention to retire. Bulger also deplored the lack of a military or police force to provide him with the power to maintain order within the colony and to preserve it from the constant threat of attack from the Sioux.

The HBC’s chief factor at Fort Garry (Winnipeg), John Clarke, quickly antagonized Bulger by officially serving notice to him that he was prohibited from trafficking in furs, and as a consequence any hope of cooperation between Bulger as civil governor and Clarke as the company’s chief representative vanished. This situation contributed to the poor state of health from which Bulger suffered for most of the winter of 1822–23. Much of the difficulty he experienced in managing the colony arose from the ill-defined relationship between the settlement and the fur trade and from the confusion surrounding the rights of the settlers, given the fur-trade monopoly granted to the HBC by its charter. Nevertheless, after learning of the dispute between Clarke and Bulger, in May 1823 the London committee of the HBC exonerated the governor and condemned their own officer as “imprudent and indiscreet,” and on some counts “preposterous and indecorous.”

Bulger had written a lengthy letter to Colvile in December 1822 about the state of the colony. He recommended that a system of courts and magistrates be set up, that a company of troops be sent to the colony to enforce the laws and keep the natives in order, that the settlers be allowed to purchase provisions and skins for clothing from the Indians and Métis, and that money be circulated. He also asked Colvile to find a market for the colony’s surplus grain. “If these things cannot be done,” he warned, “spend no more of Lord Selkirk’s money upon Red River.”

Although his recommendations concerning provisions and currency were implemented by return post, the appeal for troops and markets remained unsatisfied for many years. Bulger left Red River in August 1823 and returned to England. Although he had made enemies in the colony and was later criticized by HBC governor George Simpson as wasteful and extravagant, he had inspired confidence and loyalty in his councillors and was appreciated by the settlers who credited him with bringing peace and prosperity to the settlement. In the summer of 1825 Bulger sailed for Quebec to become principal and confidential clerk to the military secretary. His health, never again robust, continued to deteriorate. He was nonetheless conscientious and industrious in the service of Quebec’s various military secretaries. In 1839 he moved with the civil administration to Montreal, where he continued to serve faithfully until his death on 2 March 1858 (Dictionary of Canadian Biography refers).

Sold with 30pp photocopy of An Autobiographical Sketch of the Services of the Late Captain Andrew Bulger of the Royal Newfoundland Fencible Regiment, printed at the Regimental Press, 2nd Battalion 10th Regiment, Bangalore, 1865, which contains a detailed and fascinating account of his services during the war.

Withdrawn